General Categories > Open Flourish | General Discussion

Modified videos

(1/2) > >>

Ken Fraser:
I'd ban the posting of speeded-up videos which are misleading and give the wrong impression of skill and dexterity. This must be particularly disheartening to beginners. Instagram is very guilty of this practice.

Does anyone agree...or is this just the griping of an out-of-touch old dinosaur. :(


AnasaziWrites:

--- Quote from: Ken Fraser on November 23, 2023, 06:57:29 AM ---I'd ban the posting of speeded-up videos which are misleading and give the wrong impression of skill and dexterity. This must be particularly disheartening to beginners. Instagram is very guilty of this practice.

Does anyone agree...or is this just the griping of an out-of-touch old dinosaur. :(

--- End quote ---
@Ken Fraser
Agree 100%. Very misleading. I enjoy seeing the speed at which people actually write.

Erica McPhee:
LOL! I agree to a certain extent. I really appreciate watching other calligraphers in real time because itís helpful to see how fast or slow they work. But on Instagram there used to be a time limit for videos and if you want to see the whole thing, it has to be sped up. Also, sometimes itís just fun to see it all in one swoop.

And, Iíll be honest, there are some that are so incredibly slow, I never make it past the first couple strokes because [yawn].  ;D :-[

brose:
Counterpoint: the exposure could inspire those who may otherwise never know or see calligraphy. Unfortunately, media is going after shorter attention spans. Slow real time videos have less of a chance of getting fast attention, going viral, and providing exposure to those who would have otherwise maybe never know about it.

This is one of those things where I am not a huge fan, but I get the reasoning.

Ken Fraser:

--- Quote from: Erica McPhee on November 23, 2023, 11:02:01 AM ---And, Iíll be honest, there are some that are so incredibly slow, I never make it past the first couple strokes because [yawn].  ;D :-[

--- End quote ---
I can see that very quick videos can be entertaining as they are obviousiy faked. My problem is with videos which have been slightly quickened. This is presumably to give the impression of greater skill. This must be misleading to the uninitiated and is simply a form of cheating IMHO. As Tom Gourdie once famously said "in calligraphy nobody ever won a prize by coming first".
I, personally, have no problem with slowly executed calligraphy which, if well done, can be beautiful to watch.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

Go to full version