31
Tools & Supplies / New/Old Ink/Nib Test
« on: January 16, 2022, 12:04:25 PM »
The topic of when to throw away a nib and replace it with a new one comes up once in a while, and, more rarely, when to throw out ink and replace it with fresh. I'm one who is reluctant to throw away a nib, perhaps because the nibs I use most frequently are hard and somewhat expensive to replace. Nevertheless, when the nib won't give proper hairlines (the most obvious clue) on any paper or with any ink, out it goes. This might occur after 5-10 pages of writing or maybe 50-75 (?) envelopes addressed. Never really precisely kept track. It's one of those things you know it when you see it.
Ink is another matter. Its usefulness seems to degrade much more slowly over time and vary among the various types of ink. I have some rarely used inks over 10 years old which still seem to work well. My go to ink is McCaffery's Penman's Black, and I keep a once ounce bottle on my desk all the time, topping it off as needed from a master bottle. Every 6-18 months, I dump the bottle and start with new. Last week, I dumped the one ounce bottle, which lasted about a year, I think, and it had about 1/4 inch of near solid sludge at the bottom, which, if I wasn't careful, would mix in somewhat with the new added ink and cause problems.
So, with the new year, out with the old and in with the new, both ink and nibs in the five pens I use most--three with Gillott 604ef nibs (two for iron gall ink, one for non-iron gall, mostly colored inks), one with a Spencerian #1 nib, and one with a vintage Gillott 303.
I've compared the nibs/ink, old and new, starting with one of the G604ef nibs (the others I'll test as I use them). What a difference.
Morale of the story for me--change the ink and nibs more often, and bear the cost.
Ink is another matter. Its usefulness seems to degrade much more slowly over time and vary among the various types of ink. I have some rarely used inks over 10 years old which still seem to work well. My go to ink is McCaffery's Penman's Black, and I keep a once ounce bottle on my desk all the time, topping it off as needed from a master bottle. Every 6-18 months, I dump the bottle and start with new. Last week, I dumped the one ounce bottle, which lasted about a year, I think, and it had about 1/4 inch of near solid sludge at the bottom, which, if I wasn't careful, would mix in somewhat with the new added ink and cause problems.
So, with the new year, out with the old and in with the new, both ink and nibs in the five pens I use most--three with Gillott 604ef nibs (two for iron gall ink, one for non-iron gall, mostly colored inks), one with a Spencerian #1 nib, and one with a vintage Gillott 303.
I've compared the nibs/ink, old and new, starting with one of the G604ef nibs (the others I'll test as I use them). What a difference.
Morale of the story for me--change the ink and nibs more often, and bear the cost.