5
« on: March 22, 2020, 12:37:24 AM »
I'll admit to frequently nerding out to some YouTube videos about all things calligraphy. Recently, I've come across quite a few videos where the calligrapher is using a plain old #2 pencil. There are also a few videos of people using 0.7mm mechanical pencils. All of them look great, but the ensuing comments after each video is downright nauseating, and wreaks of condescension. Everything from "the x-heights are incorrect" (to be fair, they're not), to "are you sure youve got the right slant for that script?" So, I got to thinking about a post I made many years ago, as to who is to say what is, or is not, proper calligraphy. Naturally, I remembered that I am a member here, so I wanted to get your opinions.
1. Is Copperplate script, done in pencil, still considered Copperplate script if the angles, shading, and spacing are correct? Why, or why not?
2. Why is it that a script with a 55° slant is one script, but a script written with the exact same shading, and even spacing, but written at a 40° slant magically transforms the script to something else?